Proposal DC Management

From Audacity Wiki
Revision as of 10:03, 8 July 2008 by PeterSampson (talk | contribs) (detailed discussion page linked from GR for DC management)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to: navigation, search

Page linked from Feature Requests for more detailed discussion

Koz wrote: I want to subtract a feature. I want Audacity to not pass DC. Ever.

I've seen the analysis coating the blackboard of why you need audio to respond all the way down to DC, but I'm here to tell you that it causes far more problems than it cures. DC is not sound and never has been.

I had to do some audio production in the field without my Cool Edit license, so naturally I fired up my Audacity. I got as far as adding silent stretches to the production and couldn't do it. It turned out, quite a bit later, that my show had a significant DC level on it and the silence generator didn't. I'm not in the habit of looking for non-audio signals in my audio show. It was a nasty surprise and should not have happened.

It could be argued that scientists use Audacity for its ability to manage data signals. Terrific. There can be a data version for those six people.

Stevethefiddle wrote: That is really something that your sound card should do (or rather, not do).

I guess it would be quite easy to implement by passing all new audio (recorded or imported) through a low frequency high pass filter, but there would (inevitably?) be some processing time overhead involved, so is it fair to impose this overhead on everyone just because some users have faulty hardware?

Koz wrote: the number of times this comes up, I'm betting a lot of people have local offset problems and either just haven't complained about it, or don't realize it's broken. No, people, effects are not supposed to pop, thump, and click when you apply them.

And audio programs are not supposed to pass out-of-band energy--either direction. I'm perfectly happy to have a preference where you can force Audacity to pass everything from DC to 100KHz, but it's not an audio editor in that case. Hewlett-Packard, Fluke, and other manufacturers call those signal generators and amplifiers, not audio products.

Waxcylinder wrote: Perhaps it should be a Preferences setting - but if so, the default should definitely be "Do not pass DC".

Gale Andrews wrote: I suspect from memory of responses made in the past we'd not want to get involved modifying the signal in this way, even if it were technically possible (and I don't know enough about this kind of thing to comment in detail)... I know it doesn't stop the loss of headroom occurring, but a Feature Request for automatic removal of DC offset after recording (rather than just as an option in Normalize) might have more chance of being implemented).