Difference between revisions of "Proposal Space Savers"

From Audacity Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(Elimination of two more toolbars.)
(Developer Backing: removing my negative vote)
 
(4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 12: Line 12:
  
 
* [[User:James| James Crook]]
 
* [[User:James| James Crook]]
 
  
 
== Use Cases ==
 
== Use Cases ==
Line 21: Line 20:
 
==Reduced Toolbars Prototype==
 
==Reduced Toolbars Prototype==
  
* Combine the mixer and meter toolbars so that the microphone and speaker icons aren't repeated, the slider gets longer travel for more accuracy, and one toolbar saved.
+
* Combine the Mixer and Meter toolbars so that the microphone and speaker icons aren't repeated, the slider gets longer travel for more accuracy, and one toolbar saved.
  
 
[[Image:MeterWithSlider.png|750px|link=]]
 
[[Image:MeterWithSlider.png|750px|link=]]
Line 30: Line 29:
  
  
A further change is to get rid of the tools toolbar and switch entirely to multi-tool mode.  It may be desirable to convert the envelope tool button into a toggle that shows/hides the envelope, and move it to a single height toolbar such as the edit toolbar.  An alternative option is to only show an envelope if the envelope has 1 or more control points.  You would then use the track drop down menu to create such an envelope, if none were shown.
+
A further change is to get rid of the Tools toolbar and switch entirely to Multi-Tool mode.  It may be desirable to convert the Envelope tool button into a toggle that shows/hides the envelope, and move it to a single height toolbar such as the Edit toolbar.  An alternative option is to only show an envelope if the envelope has 1 or more control points.  You would then use the track drop down menu to create such an envelope, if none were shown.
  
 
==Multiple tracks==
 
==Multiple tracks==
Line 56: Line 55:
 
[[File:TCP.png]]
 
[[File:TCP.png]]
  
* Again, mute and solo move up
+
* Again, Mute and Solo move up
 
* Pan slider becomes a dial, to the right of the gain slider
 
* Pan slider becomes a dial, to the right of the gain slider
 
* Title of track becomes vertical and is moved to left of TCP
 
* Title of track becomes vertical and is moved to left of TCP
** Drop-down menu moves to right of mute/solo
+
** Dropdown menu moves to right of Mute/Solo
 
** Length of title shown now depends on track height
 
** Length of title shown now depends on track height
 
** An alternative is to show the title on the new/proposed clip grabber
 
** An alternative is to show the title on the new/proposed clip grabber
 
* Ruler removed (it becomes an opt-in feature)
 
* Ruler removed (it becomes an opt-in feature)
 
 
  
 
==Track Groups==
 
==Track Groups==

Latest revision as of 08:53, 11 May 2021

Proposal pages help us get from feature requests into actual plans. This page is a mix of proposals for saving space in the GUI.
Proposal pages are used on an ongoing basis by the Audacity development team and are open to edits from visitors to the wiki. They are a good way to get community feedback on a proposal.


  • Note: Proposals for Google Summer of Code projects are significantly different in structure, are submitted via Google's web app and may or may not have a corresponding proposal page.


Proposed Feature

  • Various features to save space on the Audacity interface.
  • The most important ones save space on the track panel.


Developer Backing

Use Cases

  • Users working with large numbers of tracks. Five or more is large in this context.
  • Users who like an uncluttered distraction free user interface.

Reduced Toolbars Prototype

  • Combine the Mixer and Meter toolbars so that the microphone and speaker icons aren't repeated, the slider gets longer travel for more accuracy, and one toolbar saved.

MeterWithSlider.png

  • Same thing, but with LED meter for sharper ability to read levels. This has been implemented and released in DarkAudacity. Additionally the device toolbar goes, removing more duplication of speaker and microphone icons. Instead the speaker and microphone buttons call up a configuration dialog.

LedMeter2.png


A further change is to get rid of the Tools toolbar and switch entirely to Multi-Tool mode. It may be desirable to convert the Envelope tool button into a toggle that shows/hides the envelope, and move it to a single height toolbar such as the Edit toolbar. An alternative option is to only show an envelope if the envelope has 1 or more control points. You would then use the track drop down menu to create such an envelope, if none were shown.

Multiple tracks

There can be many more tracks in a project than can be displayed easily on one screen. Solutions:

Redesigned Track Control Panel

Done.png Suggestion by Sergei Chebankov: Currently if the vertical track height is set so that Mute and Solo buttons appear, the track takes about 90 pixels (Track "STE-000" in the image below) and not many tracks fit into the screen.

Space-saving Track Control Panel with mute/solo at top and rollup button to left of it


How about swapping vertically the order of "Mute/Solo" segment and the segment displaying track data ("Stereo, 48000Hz,32-bit float", STE-001). In such case the height of a track with still visible Mute/Solo buttons can go down to about 58 pixels.

Additionally, it would be even better to combine the Mute/Solo buttons and the roll-up/down arrow button into one segment (STE-006). This would allow the minimal 40-pixel-high display of a track to have the most necessary bits on the left panel - its name (with dropdown arrow) and the Mute/Solo and restore buttons.

Qt Track Panel Prototype

Here's another variant:
TCP.png

  • Again, Mute and Solo move up
  • Pan slider becomes a dial, to the right of the gain slider
  • Title of track becomes vertical and is moved to left of TCP
    • Dropdown menu moves to right of Mute/Solo
    • Length of title shown now depends on track height
    • An alternative is to show the title on the new/proposed clip grabber
  • Ruler removed (it becomes an opt-in feature)

Track Groups

The Shift-Ctrl-F (auto-fit all tracks) feature in Audacity 1.2.6 does a good job of making all the tracks visible in a project with many tracks. However the tracks end up having to be of very shallow height to fit on screen. Mute buttons etc. become hidden. As long as there are not too many tracks, that problem can be overcome by redesign of the Track Control Panel (see above), but the difficulty remains with really large numbers of tracks. The same issue can occur in Adobe Photoshop (a graphics image editor) if an image has many "layers". An elegant solution to this problem has been implemented in recent versions of Photoshop in the "layers palette". The same idea would work very well in Audacity. This is how it would work, translated into Audacity language:

  1. A menu option "Create new TRACK GROUP" creates something that looks like a new track - it has a name, delete, balance, volume, mute and solo buttons - but it is not an audio track - it is a track "set" or "folder" or "group" or "collection". It also has an expand/collapse button on the left. I will call this thing a "group" for now.
  2. Let's name this group "Rhythm", for example.
  3. If any audio tracks are dragged onto the "Rhythm" group they are displayed under that group.
  4. But if the "collapse" button of the "Rhythm" group is clicked then the single "group" track is displayed as one horizontal strip but all the audio tracks inside it are hidden from view.
  5. Balance, volume, mute and solo buttons on the Rhythm group strip control the playback of all the audio tracks inside that group (though each audio track still has its own specific settings).
  6. The Rhythm group, and other groups, can be manipulated in their collapsed state by dragging up and down, collapsing, expanding, muting, adjusting volume, etc.
  7. Individual audio tracks can be dragged from group to group, or dragged out of a group completely.
  8. The visual appearance of the waveform area of a "group" strip could be just blank, or it could show for instance a simple normalised sum of all the audio tracks inside - that would aid usability.
  9. Most of the audio editing functions would NOT be implemented for working on a "group" - that would still be done on the individual audio tracks visible in an expanded group.

Here is an example of what a user might create in a working project using this idea: Groups named "Rhythm", "Vocals", "Backing", "Count-in", "Roughwork", "Soundeffects", and "ScratchPad". Each group might contain about five separate audio tracks. That would be about thirty-five audio tracks in the project. Most of the groups would be displayed in the collapsed state with just one group expanded. All the tracks in the project would be available to view as desired without the confusion of all the tracks being in one unwieldy long scrolling list.