Talk:Completed: Proposal sha.txt

From Audacity Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Original Proposed Feature (now simplified)

The idea is simple. We add an optional text file 'sha.txt' that QA uses and that we may or may not ship with Audacity depending on whether we decide it is useful beyond QA. This file has SHAs from Git and descriptive strings. When we build audacity, the build script includes the SHA of the git branch audacity was built from in audacity.exe. That is not hard. (we dynamically create a #include file with the SHA in, which we throw away after compiling). When audacity displays the build info window, it checks for sha.txt and if present also shows revision descriptive text from sha.txt in the build info window, or default text if no shas.txt is present.

The code to get the SHA, which can be part of the build script, is:

git rev-parse master

The descriptive text can be any text we decide on for that hash. It could also include a link to the relevant commit. The build info window is html after all. So a tester can open the build info window and see what revision of code the build is from. They do not need to see the hash if we don't want that to show. Instead they could see some descriptive text and a link to the commit. If we don't want this information visible to most users, we don't ship the sha.txt file with audacity.

Now what if sha.txt is in our VCS? Does that cause a problem? No. The sha in audacity.exe is for the audacity source. It doesn't change if sha.txt is updates as sha.txt isn't used in building audacity.

This solution is only for audacity source code revision numbers. There is also a case for some kind of revision number for builds, zips and installers. That is a related problem and is best solved by using the object's checksum. Being clear that revision numbers in builds identify the source code, not the build means there isn't a circular problem. Builds made with different compiler tools, gcc, MSVC, tcc, will be different, but can have the same source revision number. By contrast a checksum uniquely identifies a build zip or installer, and has to live 'outside' it.

Audacity can determine its own checksum, and it can look that up in sha.txt. So we could add checksums into sha.txt too. There is less need for this, as we have checksum tools, so my suggestion is that we do the sha part first.